Reference: Massey, D., 1991, “A global sense of place” Marxism Today (38) 24-29
Massey is writing in response to what she calls the effects of time-space compression (the simultaneous spreading out and concentration of space and time) on our notions of place.
How can we rethink our views of place so that they are progressive and outward looking?
How can we maintain identity if there are no boundaries, no fixity, no difference?
How can we hold onto the rootedness of ‘place’ without being defensive and reactionary?
Massey argues that the idea that places have a single ‘essential’ identity based on a bounded history of a territorial place is flawed. Place as rooted in a locality or a territorially based community is often romanticised and we should question the value of considering place in this way: “place and locality are a foci for a form of romanticised escapism from the real business of the world” (p.26). In her view, if place seen in these terms becomes a static, dead object whilst time is seen as a progressive, socially produced, relational process.
She argues that there is a desire for fixity and boundaries from otherness as a form of protecting identities from the flux changes and influences of the outside world. However this denies the fact that the ‘other’ is already within. Not only this, but what has always constituted that place has been the influences of the ‘other’ the global. All the relations that have passed through that place are what makes its constantly evolving identity.
“If one moves in from the satellite towards the globe, holding all those networks of social relations and movements and communications in one’s head, then each ‘place’ can be seen as a particular, unique, point of their intersection. It is, indeed, a meeting place. Instead then, of thinking of places as areas with boundaries around, they can be imagined as articulated moments in networks of social relations and understandings, but where a large proportion of those relations, experiences and understandings are constructed on a far larger scale than what we happen to define for that moment as the place itself, whether that be a street, or a region or even a continent. And this in turn allows a sense of place which is extroverted, which includes a consciousness of its links with the wider world, which integrates in a positive way the global and the local.” (p.28)
Massey talks about the political implications of the ‘space of places’ in relation to ‘the space of flows’ (see Castells). Her central concern is the politics of mobility: “mobility and control over mobility both reflects and reinforces power” (p.25). In other words the power of some mobility can weaken the mobility of others. Take social mobility for example: by increasing university fees, this is enabling richer students to access education and as a consequence it is limiting the power of poorer students to access a good education. Massey used the term power geometries to define the idea of power in relation to flows.
Another thing to note is our ‘geographies of responsibility’ – although the local is often seen as the victim of global forces, it is within local places that global actions take place. In other words, the local is responsible for the global.
What are the critiques of Massey’s call for a ‘global sense of place’?
What are the implications of this ‘networked’ view of space on our notions of place? Can a sense of place exist without the idea of territory?
To what extent does Massey’s idea of a global sense of place encompass the potential of the term in geographical thinking (the essay question)?
These issues were addressed in one of our seminars on Massey. Notes from the seminar are below.
Thinking Space seminar 3: Doreen Massey, 20th October, 2011
What constitutes a place other than it’s networks?
1. The relationship between places and wider connections in politics:
- it is in the wider connections which created meaning – the politics of openness
- is there something important about places that Massey misses?
- Perhaps the subject itself is the site of dynamism – affect, experience
2. Other sources of openness in the politics of place:
- where does the story of constructing identities around connections leave place-based meaning?
- Meaning is grounded – psychoanalysis, experiences, meaningful attachments, these are what create places – not necessarily connections with external places/ difference.
– Nichols talks about moments of collective organizing
– Escobar – talks about where we are now, the here and now, place is what matters to us, not abstract spaces
– Massey argues that all meaning is relational – all constructed through constantly changing networks and connections. Meaning is constructed through openness.
– However there are internal subjective processes that provide meaning that are being ignored.
– For Massey, flows exist at all scales: even the transference from emotion to language is a flow of discourse on the smallest scale.
– But can looking inwardly create the development of ideas too or does it always require stimulation from external influences? We then talked in a small group about the notion of ‘affect’ which I think is all a load of meaningless…
Other sources of openness…
– Affecture, emotional, historical/ temporal, subjectivity
– Even if you reduce the transnational movement of individuals they will always be located in a place which will affect their views
– I think identity is defined by difference, difference is defined by boundaries. Therefore is identity defined by boundaries? (problem of induction)
– Politics is based on identity and difference
– Does openness destroy identity? – openness can create no difference so does it mean you lose identity? Is it actually producing homogeneity rather than heterogeneity?
– We seem to have an inherent affectual need for identity
A politics of openness vs. defensive space…
– Massey argues that place is provided with politics by linking up with the other and therefore creating multiplicity.
– Another view is that place is a site of particularity – with its own meaning and identity which is separate from networks. They have their own resources e.g. social capital (and the place itself becomes a resource)
What are the things/ social processes that we need to pay attention to? What makes a place other than its networks? What constitutes a place?
Openness creates more defensive space: the distant is present even without connections through proximity (see John Allen).
[ Further reading ]
Interview with Massey in 2009
Featherstone, D. (2003), Spatialities of transnational resistance to globalization: the maps of grievance of the Inter-Continental Caravan. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 28: 404–421.
Featherstone, D. (2005), Towards the Relational Construction of Militant Particularisms: Or Why the Geographies of Past Struggles Matter for Resistance to Neoliberal Globalisation. Antipode, 37: 250–271
Massey, D., 1993, “Power-geometry and a progressive sense of place” in Mapping the futures: local cultures, global change Eds Bird, J., Curtis, B., Putnam, T. and Tickner, L.(Routledge, London).
Massey, D., 2004, “Geographies of responsibility” Geographiska Annaler B 86 5-18
Massey, D., 2005 For space (Sage, London) (more philosophically nuanced defence of this approach)
Massey, D. and Jess, P. 1995. A Place in the World? Oxford: Oxford University Press. (an accessible introduction to this approach)
Urban Studies, 1997, 34, 2, 355-66(review of A Place in the World?)
Mayer, M., 2008, “To what end do we theorize sociospatial relations?” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 26 414-419
Swyngedouw, E. 2004. Globalisation or ‘Glocalisation’? Networks, Territories and Rescaling. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 17, 1: 25-48.
This article is about the geographer. For the Labour Party politician, see Doreen Massey, Baroness Massey of Darwen.
Doreen Barbara MasseyFRSAFBAFAcSS (3 January 1944 – 11 March 2016) was a British social scientist and geographer, working among others on topics involving Marxist geography, feminist geography, and cultural geography. Her work on space, place and power has been highly influential within a range of related disciplines and research fields. She was Professor of Geography at the Open University.
Massey was born in Manchester and spent most of her childhood in Wythenshawe, a large council estate. She studied at Oxford and later at the University of Pennsylvania, from which she received a Masters in Regional Science. She began her career at a thinktank: the Centre for Environmental Studies (CES) in London. CES contained several key analysts of the contemporary British economy, and Massey established a working partnership with Richard Meegan, among others. CES was closed down. She was then Professor of Geography at the Open University.
Massey retired in 2009 but remained a frequent media commentator, particularly on industry and regional trends. As Professor Emerita at the Open University she continued her speaking engagements and involvement in educational TV programmes and books.
Doreen Massey's main fields of study are globalisation, regional uneven development, cities, and the reconceptualisation of place. Although associated with an analysis of contemporary western capitalist society, she also worked in Nicaragua, South Africa and Venezuela.
Her early work at CES established the basis for her 'spatial divisions of labour' theory (Power Geometry), that social inequalities were generated by the unevenness of the capitalist economy, creating stark divisions between rich and poor regions and between social classes. 'Space matters' for poverty, welfare and wealth. Over the years this theory has been refined and extended, with space and spatial relationships remaining central to her account of contemporary society.
Sense of place
While Massey has argued for the importance of place, her position accords with those arguing against essentialised or static notions, where:
- places do not have single identities but multiple ones.
- places are not frozen in time, they are processes.
- places are not enclosures with a clear inside and outside.
Massey used the example of Kilburn High Road in north west London to exemplify what she termed a 'progressive' or 'global' sense of place, in the essay 'A Global Sense of Place'. In a Podcast interview with Social Science Space Massey talks about the idea of physical space being alive "A lot of what I’ve been trying to do over the all too many years when I’ve been writing about space is to bring space alive, to dynamize it and to make it relevant, to emphasize how important space is in the lives in which we live. Most obviously I would say that space is not a flat surface across which we walk; Raymond Williams talked about this: you’re taking a train across the landscape – you’re not traveling across a dead flat surface that is space: you’re cutting across myriad stories going on. So instead of space being this flat surface it’s like a pincushion of a million stories: if you stop at any point in that walk there will be a house with a story. Raymond Williams spoke about looking out of a train window and there was this woman clearing the grate, and he speeds on and forever in his mind she’s stuck in that moment. But actually, of course, that woman is in the middle of doing something, it’s a story. Maybe she’s going away tomorrow to see her sister, but really before she goes she really must clean that grate out because she’s been meaning to do it for ages. So I want to see space as a cut through the myriad stories in which we are all living at any one moment. Space and time become intimately connected." 
Awards and Honours
- 2014 - Presidential Achievement Award of the Association of American Geographers
- 2013 - Honorary Doctorate, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, University of Zurich
- 2012 - Honorary Doctorate, Harokopio University, Athens
- 2010 - Hon DSc (Econ), Queen Mary University of London
- 2009 - Honorary Doctorate of Letters, University of Glasgow
- 2006 - Honorary DLitt, National University of Ireland
- 2006 - Honorary Doctorate of Science awarded by the University of Edinburgh
- 2003 - Centenary Medal of Royal Scottish Geographical Society
- 2003 - Anders Retzius Medal in Gold, awarded by the Swedish Society of Anthropologists and Geographers
- 2002 - Fellow, British Academy
- 2001 - Honorary Fellow, St. Hugh's College, University of Oxford
- 2000 - Fellow, Royal Society of Arts
- 1999 - Fellow, Academy of Social Sciences
- 1998 - Prix Vautrin Lud ('Nobel de Géographie')
- 1994 - Victoria Medal of the Royal Geographical Society
♯ Doreen Massey declined the award of an Order of the British Empire (OBE)
- Cordey-Hayes, M. & Massey, DB.. 1970. An operational urban development model of Cheshire. London: Centre for Environmental Studies.
- Massey, D.B. 1971. The basic: service categorisation in planning London: Centre for Environmental Studies.
- Massey, D.B. 1974. Towards a critique of industrial location theory London: Centre for Environmental Studies.
- Massey, D.B & Batey, P.W.J. (Eds)(1977) "Alternative Frameworks for analysis", London:Pion (ISBN 085086061X)
- Massey, D.B. & Catalano, A. (1978) Capital and land: Landownership by capital in Great Britain. London: Edward Arnold. (ISBN 0713161086 and 0713161094 pbk)
- Massey, D.B. & Meegan, R.A. (1979) The geography of industrial reorganisation: The spatial effects of the restructuring of the electrical engineering sector under the industrial reorganisation corporation. Oxford and New York: Pergamon Press.
- Massey, D.B. & Meegan, R.A. (1982) The anatomy of job loss: The how, why, and where of employment decline. London and New York: Methuen.
- Massey, D.B. (1984) Spatial divisions of labour: Social structures and the geography of production. New York: Methuen.
- Massey, D.B. (1987) Nicaragua. Milton Keynes, England and Philadelphia: Open University Press.
- Massey, D.B. (1988) Global restructuring, local responses. Atwood lecture. Worcester, Mass.: Graduate School of Geography, Clark University.
- Ginwala, F, Mackintosh, M, & Massey, D.B. (1991) Gender and economic policy in a democratic South Africa. Milton Keynes, UK: Development Policy and Practice, Technology Faculty, Open University.
- Massey, D.B. (1994) Space, place, and gender. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
- Massey, D.B. (1995) Spatial divisions of labor: Social structures and the geography of production 2nd edition. New York: Routledge.
- Hall, S., Massey, D.B., & Rustin, M. (1997) The next ten years. London: Soundings.
- Allen, J., Massey, D.B, Cochrane, A. (1998) Rethinking the region. New York: Routledge.
- Massey, D.B (2005) For Space, London: Sage (ISBN 1412903610 & ISBN 1412903629)
- Massey, D.B. (2007). World City, Cambridge: Polity Press.
- Massey, D.B. (2010). World City, published with new Preface: "After the Crash", July 2010. Cambridge: Polity Press