• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

French Canadian And English Canadian Relations Essays On The Great

Post your essay. Get expert feedback. For free.

We're trying to help students improve their writing the hard way. Do you know students who want critical essay reviews from a professor of English Literature? Click like to share. Click here to sign up and post your own essay. We offer no paid services. All reviews are completely free.

French And English Relations In Canada - With A Free Essay Review




In the moment Jacques Cartier stepped onto Canadian soil, Canada was destined to be tangled in the endless rivalry between the French and the English. Before the creation of Canada, it was merely a colony that was stuck in a tug-of-war between the French and the British over its possession. The conflict was brought over from Europe to North America. The hostility between the two ethnicities shows no signs of cooling down even after the creation of the country of Canada. The French and English relations have always been strained and the tensions between the two groups have prevented the true unification of Canada. The main causes of this unending conflict are French nationalism, their policy on language rights, and the federal and provincial conflicts.

The French Canadians have always been a small island surrounded by an ocean of English-speaking people, but the French Canadians isolate themselves further with their strong nationalistic views (Behiels 383). The French voiced their opinions constantly throughout Canada’s history, one of which was the Quiet Revolution. The main slogan of the revolution was “Masters of our own house” and the French Canadians no longer wanted to be treated like second class citizens in their own country (Bélanger, Jean 1). They wanted equal status in Confederation because they were a minority against the dominant English speaking provinces. During the 1960s, the province of Quebec was trying hard to catch up with the rest of society by slowly shedding their strict traditional Roman Catholic views and becoming more modernized (Bélanger, Quiet 1). The Liberal government led by John Levage, promised to improve the economic and social status of Quebec and to gain the recognition for the French Canadians (Anderson 1). The irony of the name of the revolution was that it was not at all “quiet”. There were many violent displays of nationalistic views and the FLQ (Front De Libération Du Québec) were mainly responsible for these events. The FLQ was a revolutionary movement, led by people who wanted the separatism of Quebec from Canada and their goal was to promote the independence of Quebec by using terrorism (Laurendeau 1). They were accountable for several bomb attacks, most of which were aimed against federal government property (Behiels 206). The FLQ abducted James Richard Cross, a British trade commissioner, on October 5, 1970. Five days afterwards, they kidnapped Pierre Laporte, the Deputy Premier of Quebec, who was later assassinated by his kidnappers on October 17, in response to the federal government’s War Measures Act (October 1). The month of October of the year of 1970 is referred to as the October Crisis because of the panic it created inside the borders of Canada. The country was once again divided between the people supporting the FLQ, mainly the people in Quebec, and the people supporting the federal government for the War Measures Act, which was the rest of Canada (Behiels 213).

In hopes of filling in the barrier between the two languages, Canada became a bilingual country. After the Quiet Revolution, the Roman Catholic faith and spiritualism were no longer relevant to the modernized people of Quebec. The only remaining characteristic the French Canadians shared was their language (Coleman 183). They felt the need to defend the survival of the language from the dominant English society in order to preserve their identity (Bothwell 153). Canada is populated with roughly 20% of the population who are French Canadians, against the rest of the population who speak either English or another language. The issue of bilingualism is the fact that the whole country has to accommodate for the special one-quarter of the population. The Quebec Board of the French Language (OQLF) or nicknamed the ‘language police’ by the English media are probably the most feared people to business owners. In Quebec, all visible form of writing must be in French, there are strict laws that indicate that the French words have to be visually larger than any other language (Belhiels 403). Maintaining the two official languages do not come cheap with a budget of 2.4 billion dollars a year (Radia 1). Even Canada’s current Prime Minister Stephen Harper commented on the cost of bilingualism in a newspaper article back in 2001, before he was elected as the prime minister.

Many Canadians question the need to go to such extents to keep Canada as a bilingual country. In order to maintain their culture and their identity, the Québécois felt responsible to be the guardian of the French-Canadian identity and in order for it to survive, the French Canadians felt the need to separate themselves from the influence of other cultures (Coleman 77). The Parti Quebecois is an example of a political party that is committed in the independence of Quebec (Fitzmaurice 182). Despite the fact that the province of Quebec has always gotten special treatment, they were not impressed with the federal government’s attempts to please them (Bélanger, Quebec 1). The PQ came to power in the year of 1976 with René Lévesque as the leader. He aimed to overturn the English dominance over Quebec (Bothwell 160). Quebec wanted more provincial power such as having all taxes in Quebec be collected by the Quebec government. In 1961, the Maisons du Quebec was opened and Quebec’s intention was to sign cultural and educational agreements with France, the federal government quickly intervened. The tension between the federal government and the rebelling Quebec government became higher after this event (Deroucher 1). Since the majority of the French Canadian population lives in Quebec, they felt responsible for them. Quebec wanted to become the national government of the French Canadians (Bélanger 1).

Was the fate of the never-ending French-English feud decided when France was defeated by the British and Canada was handed over to British regime? Ever since then, the French Canadians were forever bitter about being under the shadow of the English. Their different views on nationalism, language and politics, resulted in a divided country. Canada can never be truly a country until the relationship between the French and the English resolve.

________________________________

ESSAY REVIEW

I found the first paragraph confusing because, on the one hand, you seem to want to claim that the tension between English- and French-speaking Canadians is rooted in a long history of acrimony between the English and the French, whereas on the other hand you seem to want to lay blame for the tension predominantly on today’s French-speaking Canadians. A similar kind of problem can be seen shortly thereafter: on the one hand, the French Canadians are victims (they are surrounded by the English-speaking people and allegedly treated like second-class citizens) and on the other hand they are the cause of the problem, with their “strong nationalistic views.” The value of these opening several sentences is that they have a reasonably strong argumentative quality. What they implicitly show is the complexity of the issue, even if some of the sentences (identifying the French Canadians unambiguously as the guilty party) seem to deny that complexity.

From that point on the essay loses its strong argumentative drive and devolves into a more or less desultory presentation of historical facts whose significance you generally leave your reader to decide. You have a long passage on the FLQ intended to demonstrate the role of radical nationalism in the perpetuation of tensions between the two Canadian cultures, but you don’t explain how extensive support for the FLQ was in Quebec, or make any specific claims about how the actions of the FLQ helped to foster distrust or animosity between the French- and English-speaking Canadians. Your section on language is even less explicitly related to your argument concerning the continuing tensions. You make several factual claims, but you don’t explain their significance to your reader. Is the fact that some businesses in Quebec fear the OQLF related to the general tensions between French- and English-speaking Canadians? How does the fact that Prime Minister Harper commented on the cost of bilingualism help a reader understand those tensions?

Generally, then, your argument seems incomplete: you present factual claims in the form of evidence but don’t explicitly link the evidence to the argument you want to defend. I should also note that I think your argument appears to be a bit tendentious (especially when you say things like “the province of Quebec has always gotten special treatment”; even if that kind of statement were true, it wouldn’t necessarily help advance understanding the nature of the conflict. You do not need to inform your reader of your personal feelings about Quebec; all you need to do, and should do, is make a straightforward, methodical, rigorous, and neutral argument.

Best, EJ.

Submitted by: yoochunluv

Tagged...Quebec essay, French Canadian nationalism, essay help



French – English Relations Essay

A great man once said, "Love thy neighbor as thyself…" Unfortunately in Canada, that is not the case. For many years, hostility has existed between the two largest ethnic denominations in our country, the French and the English Canadians. Both have tried to undermine one another in aspects of religion, language, culture and politics. To understand the cause of this continuing bitter saga, one must take a journey back in time. Throughout the course of Canadian history, there were many occasions wherein the French and English Canadians have clashed but three major historical events tore the relationship into pieces. It all basically started with the Red River Rebellion which angered the English Canadians because they found Riel as a threat to the British Empire. Then a couple of years later, a war has started in 1914 which then led to the conscription act of 1917 which angered and forced the French into fighting in the war. Half a century later when things were looking good between the French and English Canadians, the October Crisis had hit which angered both the English as well as the French Canadians. Even though the feud between Canada's original ethnic groups, the French and the English started long time ago it still continues today with no sign of change towards peace and forgiveness.

The Red River Rebellion, led by Louis Riel, was one of the first major events that created the rift between the French and English Canadians. In 1869, when the Hudson's Bay Company sold the vast territory known as Rupert's Land to the Canadian government, the Métis were worried. The Métis descended from the intermarriage of Europeans with indigenous peoples and they possess elements of both cultures. They feared that the government would disregard their ownership of the Red River Settlement because they did not have papers to prove they owned the land. Louis Riel, a Métis man, took leadership and stood up for the rights of his people. He set up a provisional government in Manitoba. This act angered the English Canadians and was thought by the Canadian Government as an act of rebellion. These feelings of resentment and hostility further elevated with the execution of Thomas Scott. On the other hand, in the Roman Catholic province of Quebec, many people said Riel's actions were justified. They felt sympathetic toward Riel and his government. As one can see, this event led by a man of deep conviction and faith drove a wedge into a crack between the French and the English Canadians. Francophones regarded the Red River Rebellion a noble cause and Louis Riel a hero who stood up to protect the rights of the French-speaking Métis. The Anglophones saw the rebellion as a threat to Canada's sovereignty and Riel a traitor. This conflict of emotions would remain until the next major...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Proclamation Act Of 1763 Essay

465 words - 2 pages The Proclamation Act of 1763 was a major change for both the English and the French. The English wanted to assimilate the French. This was necessary for two reasons. One, the British had, after all, conquered them, and wished to create a full British Empire. They thought that the only way to do this was to assimilate all other cultures (except the Natives) into their culture. Two, the French were still a threat, and Quebec was the foothold...

Similarities that caused Conflict Essay

1548 words - 6 pages Conflicts in of 17th century colonial British North America have mainly been portrayed as a clash between Europeans, Native Americans, African Americans, and the French due to differences in culture, race, and religion. However, recently historians such as Ann M. Little author of Abraham and Arms and T.H Breen and Steve Innes co-authors of Myne Owne Ground, have been gathering evidence that may dispute these claims. These historians suggest that...

Eastern Woodland Indians and the Seven Years' War

1005 words - 4 pages War is always destructive and devastating for those involved leaving behind a trail of death and barren landscape leading to heartbreak and shattered lives. War has its subjugators and its defeated. One enjoys complete freedom and rights while the other has neither freedom nor rights. Defeated and broken is where the Eastern Woodland Indians found themselves after both the Seven Years' war and the American Revolution. The Europeans in their...

French and Indian War

1336 words - 5 pages The French and Indian war also known as the Seven Years war lasted from 1754 to 1763. The French and Indian war altered relations between the British and American colonies through political, economical and ideological aspects. The war was fought between the English and the American colonists in what was called the New World.The war that raged in North America through the late 1750's and early 1760's was but one part of the larger struggle between...

Quebec Separatism

1745 words - 7 pages Canada is known by outsiders to be a very peaceful country. But if you ask any Canadian they well tell you that is unfortunately not the case. For there is a large ongoing conflict between Canadians. The conflict is between the French and the English, or more specifically between Quebec and the rest of Canada. As a result of this conflict, along with some wrongdoing and propaganda. Quebec has considered and has gone as far to hold referendums...

Analyze the cultural and economic responses of TWO of the following groups to the Indians of North American before 1750: Brits, French, Spanish.

972 words - 4 pages Lucy Shen 9/9/07 1st pd. When Christopher Columbus first set foot upon the New World and began trading with the natives he incorrectly dubbed "Indians", he had no idea that his bartering would eventually lead to immense contact between the Native Americans and Europeans. Cultural and economic influences flowed both ways in this exchange of societies between Native Americans and both the French and British.France, a...

Ethnic and Linguistic Canada

1471 words - 6 pages Ethnic and Linguistic CanadaCanada has long struggled with issues of ethnicity and linguistics as the nation's large French-speaking minority struggles to maintain its linguistic and cultural heritage. However, the French-speaking Canadians are not the only political players north of the border, and as Canada becomes increasingly diverse, its politics become increasingly complex. According to a 1991 Canadian census figure, almost one...

Show how code switching can be used for strategic purposes. In what way is code switching similar to or different from style shifting as a strategic tool.

2365 words - 9 pages Codeswitching and style shifting are the two common means of communications today. The definition of code switching by Swann (2002) is "The switch between languages or language varieties, during the course of a single interaction". For example, codeswitching from the English to Swahili a seen in "Wache Mimi nielekee tauni tukutane this evening". (Let me go so...

Future of English

1456 words - 6 pages English has established itself as a world language. Like no other language English dominates different aspect of our lives. These aspects are culture, politics, finances and many others domains related to public and international life. I will have a look at some scenarios such as English losing the status of a world language or English becoming a so called dead language. I will consider English not only as a world language, but also as a language...

The History of Quebec Separatism

1679 words - 7 pages How close was Canada from being radically different from how it’s known today? 1.16%. From coast to coast, Canadians have taken pride in being united as one, which was exemplified by the exceptional patriotism showed during the recently completed Sochi Olympics. However, there is one province that seems to be opposed to the norm. One of the founding provinces of Canada, Quebec, has been lobbying for separation for decades. Québécois or the people...

Early Colonization

976 words - 4 pages In the late 1500s and early 1600s, the Americas had been discovered and establishment of the New World had begun. Spain, Portugal, England and France all led the way in early colonization. European nations were involved in the colonization of North and South America, but all had different approaches. Spain and Portugal were similar in the way they inhabited the land but had...

One thought on “French Canadian And English Canadian Relations Essays On The Great

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *